Peter Schiff Fires Back: Challenges Michael Saylor to a Debate on Investment Strategies

In recent developments within the cryptocurrency space, gold investor Peter Schiff has publicly criticized MicroStrategy’s business model, which heavily relies on Bitcoin holdings. Schiff labeled Strategy’s approach as a “fraud,” challenging company founder Michael Saylor to a debate amid a turbulent crypto market and a rebound in gold prices. This spat highlights ongoing tensions between traditional gold advocates and the rapidly evolving crypto industry, especially as Bitcoin experiences a notable decline from its all-time high.

Gold advocate Peter Schiff criticized MicroStrategy’s business model, which became the largest Bitcoin treasury holder in the world. Schiff, a well-known critic of cryptocurrencies, called Strategy’s approach a “fraud” and publicly challenged founder Michael Saylor to a debate at Binance Blockchain Week in Dubai this December. Schiff argues that Strategy’s reliance on income-oriented funds investing in high-yield preferred shares tied to Bitcoin exposes the company to potential collapse.

“MSTR’s business model relies on income-oriented funds buying its ‘high-yield’ preferred shares. But those published yields will never actually be paid. Once fund managers realize this, they’ll dump the preferreds.”

Schiff warned that once the funds recognize the instability of Strategy’s business model, the firm would be unable to raise new debt, setting off a “death spiral” for the company. This bearish outlook comes amid recent market declines, with Bitcoin falling below $99,000 and a broader downturn in the crypto treasury sector, which has seen many digital assets retrace from recent highs.

Despite the slump, gold remains resilient, defending its critical support above $4,000 per ounce. Currently trading around $4,085, gold’s price has rebounded from a brief dip below the psychologically important level. In October, gold peaked near $4,380, bolstered by a market capitalization exceeding $30 trillion before retreating to current levels.

Strategy’s net asset value, represented as its mNAV, had dipped below 1 in November but has since recovered to approximately 1.21. For a treasury company of this nature, investors generally favor an mNAV of 2 or higher; the current level indicates lingering skepticism. Strategy’s stock has declined over 50% since July, trading around $199 at present.

Meanwhile, the broader financial environment favors gold, which continues to outperform in the current macroeconomic landscape. As Bitcoin struggles to regain momentum and the crypto markets remain volatile, gold’s steady position above key support levels underscores its status as a safe haven amid the turbulence.