Close Menu
Crypto Breaking News
    Crypto Breaking News
    • News
      • Press Release
      • Featured
      • Events
      • Exchanges
      • Bitcoin
      • Ethereum
      • Solana
      • Ripple
      • Artificial Intelligence (AI)
      • Real World Assets (RWA)
      • Markets & Finance
      • Regulation & Policy
      • Press Releases by PR Newswire
      • News by CoinPedia
      • News by Coincu
      • News by Blockchain Wire
    • Crypto
      • Companies
      • Events
      • Partners
      • Buy Crypto
      • Timers
    • Advertise
      • Submit a Press Release
      • Logos
      • About
      • Services
    • Offers
      • Marketing Services
      • Wallets & Tools
    • Account
    • Video
    • Contact
    Submit PR
    Crypto Breaking News
    Crypto News Exchanges

    Better Markets Calls CFTC the Wrong Regulator for Retail Crypto

    6 October 2026
    FacebookTwitterLinkedInCopy Link
    News Feed
    Google NewsRSS
    Better Markets Calls Cftc The Wrong Regulator For Retail Crypto
    Better Markets Calls Cftc The Wrong Regulator For Retail Crypto

    The US Commodity Futures Trading Commission has opened a public comment process on a proposed framework aimed at regulating certain retail crypto transactions that involve margin, leverage, or financing. The move has drawn a sharp response from Better Markets, which argues that the CFTC is the wrong regulator for protecting everyday investors in crypto.

    Earlier this year, lawmakers failed to advance the CLARITY Act, prompting both the CFTC and the Securities and Exchange Commission to signal they may move forward under existing authorities rather than wait for new legislation. Against that backdrop, Better Markets says the CFTCโ€™s approach risks leaving retail users with weaker safeguards than those that apply to securities markets.

    Key takeaways

    • Better Markets says the CFTCโ€™s regulatory mission lacks an explicit investor-protection mandate comparable to the SECโ€™s securities-focused authority.
    • The CFTC is seeking public comment on a framework that would cover certain margined, leveraged, or financed retail crypto transactions under existing powers.
    • Better Markets challenges the legal rationale for CFTC oversight and disputes claims that Congress intended the agency to be a primary retail crypto regulator.
    • The proposal also contemplates a new federal category for qualifying crypto trading platforms that would bring eligible exchanges under CFTC oversight.
    • SEC activity continues in parallel, including custody-related proposals for advisers and additional crypto-related securities guidance.

    Better Markets argues retail crypto needs securities-style protections

    In its comments, Better Markets pointed to a core institutional distinction between the regulators. Benjamin Schiffrin, director of securities policy at the nonprofit financial reform advocacy group, said the CFTC does not have the same investor-protection responsibility as the SEC.

    Schiffrin argued that the CFTCโ€™s mandate has historically focused on commodity and derivatives markets dominated by large institutions with limited retail participation. In that context, he warned that applying CFTC rules to crypto transactions marketed to retail customers could mean losing protections that investors would otherwise receive in securities regulation.

    โ€œUnlike the SEC, the CFTC lacks an investor protection mandate,โ€ Schiffrin said, adding that โ€œbecause the CFTCโ€™s rules lack the protections that apply when investors trade securities regulated by the SEC, the CFTC is the wrong agency to regulate transactions involving crypto assets by retail customers.โ€

    Dispute over statutory intent and the โ€œcrypto capitalโ€ message

    Better Markets also challenged the premise behind the CFTCโ€™s authority. Schiffrin noted that the statutory authority the CFTC is relying on was originally enacted to address fraud in leveraged precious-metals trading, and he argued that this history does not necessarily demonstrate Congress intended the CFTC to become the main regulator for retail crypto activity.

    Beyond jurisdictional questions, Better Markets criticized the proposed frameworkโ€™s potential structure and its implications for market relationships. According to Schiffrin, the framework could permit affiliations between market participants in ways that he said contributed to the conditions behind FTXโ€™s collapse.

    Separately, Schiffrin took issue with CFTC Chair Mike Seligโ€™s statements about making the United States the โ€œcrypto capitalโ€ of the world. Better Marketsโ€™ position, as reflected in Schiffrinโ€™s remarks, was that the concept is unsupported and that cryptoโ€™s real-world utility remains limitedโ€”used largely for speculation or for criminal activity.

    That characterization was contested by industry participants. Nate Geraci, president of NovaDius Wealth Management, pushed back on the framing, arguing that the industry is primarily seeking clearer โ€œrules of the road.โ€ He suggested that if Congress cannot provide that clarity, regulators like the CFTC and SEC may need to fill the gap.

    CFTC proposal includes a new category for crypto platforms

    The CFTCโ€™s filing seeks public comment on a potential regulatory approach for retail crypto transactions involving margin, leverage, or financing. While Better Markets focused heavily on investor protection and regulatory fit, the proposal itself reportedly also includes a structural element: it considers creating a new federal category for qualifying crypto trading platforms that would bring eligible exchanges directly under CFTC oversight.

    For market participants, that kind of categorization matters because it can determine which rule set applies, how compliance burdens are allocated, and which regulator becomes the primary supervisory authority for certain venues. It also signals that the CFTC is not limiting its work to transaction-level conduct; it is contemplating governance for the trading venues connected to these retail activities.

    The public comment process represents an early checkpoint. The framework is still subject to feedback and potential revision before any final rules are adopted.

    Regulators move forward as Congress stalls CLARITY

    Better Marketsโ€™ critique arrives at a time when US crypto policy is increasingly shaped by regulatory action under existing laws rather than by new legislation. The CLARITY Actโ€”an effort to provide clearer statutory treatment for parts of the crypto marketโ€”failed to advance in Congress, pushing the CFTC and SEC to proceed with their own approaches.

    The SEC, meanwhile, has also continued to advance crypto-related measures. The input references SEC proposals including easing certain custody rules for investment advisers, a separate move toward allowing limited tokenized US stock trading, and the issuance of new guidance on how securities laws apply to crypto assets.

    Taken together, the parallel paths illustrate a key tension facing retail users: different regulators may apply different frameworks to crypto activity depending on how transactions and platforms are categorizedโ€”an issue Better Markets says could leave investors worse off if CFTC rules do not replicate the investor protections associated with securities oversight.

    What to watch as comments close in

    As the CFTCโ€™s consultation moves forward, readers should focus on whether the final framework meaningfully addresses investor safeguards for retail participants and how it would treat relationships among market participants and eligible trading venues. With the SEC simultaneously advancing its own crypto measures, the outcome of this comment process may help determine how US crypto oversight will be splitโ€”or reconciledโ€”going forward.

    Risk & affiliate notice: Crypto assets are volatile and capital is at risk. This article may contain affiliate links. Read full disclosure

    Crypto Breaking News
    • Website
    • Facebook
    • X (Twitter)
    • Pinterest
    • Instagram
    • Tumblr
    • LinkedIn

    The Crypto Breaking News editorial team curates the latest news, updates, and insights from the global cryptocurrency and blockchain industry.

    Related Posts

    Wrapped Monero Drops 99.8% After Suspected $13.5m Exploit

    Wrapped Monero Drops 99.8% After Suspected $13.5M Exploit

    29 minutes ago
    Dbs Strategy Tests โ€œlose Deposit, Keep Clientโ€ Retention Plan

    DBS Strategy Tests โ€œLose Deposit, Keep Clientโ€ Retention Plan

    1 hour ago
    Wrapped Monero Token Drops 99.8% After Suspected $13.5m Exploit

    Wrapped Monero Token Drops 99.8% After Suspected $13.5M Exploit

    2 hours ago
    Sky Protocol Reports $2b Stablecoin Outflows As It Denies Illicit Claims

    Sky Protocol Reports $2B Stablecoin Outflows as It Denies Illicit Claims

    4 hours ago
    Bitcoin Falls To $60k As Tech Sell-Off Hits Anthropic Token To $87

    Bitcoin Falls to $60K as Tech Sell-Off Hits Anthropic Token to $87

    5 hours ago
    Bitcoin Drops Below $60k For First Time Since July As Market Sells Off

    Bitcoin Drops Below $60K for First Time Since July as Market Sells Off

    6 hours ago

    Search Crypto News

    Featured Crypto News

    Solarious Wins Financefeeds Awards 2026 For Innovation In Renewable Energy Tokenization

    Solarious Wins FinanceFeeds Awards 2026 for Innovation in Renewable Energy Tokenization

    19 November 2026
    How Web3 Companies Can Help Educate The Next Generation: Inside Share To Care World's Mission

    How Web3 Companies Can Help Educate the Next Generation: Inside Share To Care World’s Mission

    14 November 2026

    Latest News

    • Wrapped Monero Drops 99.8% After Suspected $13.5M Exploit
    • DBS Strategy Tests โ€œLose Deposit, Keep Clientโ€ Retention Plan
    • Wrapped Monero Token Drops 99.8% After Suspected $13.5M Exploit
    • Sky Protocol Reports $2B Stablecoin Outflows as It Denies Illicit Claims
    • Bitcoin Falls to $60K as Tech Sell-Off Hits Anthropic Token to $87
    • Bitcoin Drops Below $60K for First Time Since July as Market Sells Off
    • US Senate Advances Prediction-Market Limits Under DEATH BETS Act
    • Lagarde Warns Europe Risks Falling Behind in Tokenized Markets Unity
    • Binance Blockchain Week 2026 in Bangkok to run Nov 28-29, with agenda spanning stablecoins, tokenized assets and AI in finance
    • Lagarde Says Europe Risks Missing Window to Unify Tokenized Markets

    Join 20,000+ Crypto Followers

    • Facebook2.4K
    • Twitter4.5K
    • Instagram7.2K
    • LinkedIn4.3K
    • Telegram55
    • Threads1000
    Bitpanda
    eToro Crypto 300x300

    About Crypto Breaking News

    About Crypto Breaking News

    Crypto Breaking News is a fast-growing digital media platform focused on the latest developments in cryptocurrency, blockchain, and Web3 technologies. Our goal is to provide fast, reliable, and insightful content that helps our readers stay ahead in the ever-evolving digital asset space.

    Web3 Digital L.L.C-FZ
    License Number: 2527596
    ๐Ÿ“ž +971 50 449 2025
    โœ‰๏ธ info@cryptobreaking.com
    ๐Ÿ“Meydan Grandstand, 6th floor, Meydan Road, Nad Al Sheba, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

    FacebookX (Twitter)InstagramPinterestYouTubeTumblrBlueskyLinkedInRedditTikTokTelegramThreadsRSS

    Links

    • Crypto News
    • Submit a Press Release
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Disclaimer
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Stocks Breaking News

    advertising

    © 2026 CryptoBreaking.com | All rights reserved | Powered by Web3 Digital & Osom One

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    Change Location
    Find awesome listings near you!