Close Menu
Crypto Breaking News
    Crypto Breaking News
    • News
      • Press Release
      • Featured
      • Events
      • Exchanges
      • Bitcoin
      • Ethereum
      • Solana
      • Ripple
      • Artificial Intelligence (AI)
      • Real World Assets (RWA)
      • Markets & Finance
      • Regulation & Policy
      • Press Releases by PR Newswire
      • News by CoinPedia
      • News by Coincu
      • News by Blockchain Wire
    • Crypto
      • Companies
      • Events
      • Partners
      • Buy Crypto
      • Timers
    • Advertise
      • Submit a Press Release
      • Logos
      • About
      • Services
    • Offers
      • Marketing Services
      • Wallets & Tools
    • Account
    • Video
    • Contact
    Submit PR
    Crypto Breaking News
    Crypto News Exchanges

    Better Markets Challenges CFTC as Wrong Regulator for Retail Crypto

    6 October 2026
    FacebookTwitterLinkedInCopy Link
    News Feed
    Google NewsRSS
    Better Markets Challenges Cftc As Wrong Regulator For Retail Crypto
    Better Markets Challenges Cftc As Wrong Regulator For Retail Crypto

    The U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission has moved to solicit public comment on a proposed framework for margined, leveraged, or financed retail crypto transactionsโ€”an initiative that has drawn sharp criticism from Better Markets. The financial reform nonprofit argues that placing such activities under the CFTCโ€™s umbrella could leave consumers with weaker protections than those typically available under the SEC.

    Better Marketsโ€™ concerns arrive as both the CFTC and SEC continue advancing crypto-related policy efforts after the legislative โ€œCLARITY Actโ€ stalled in Congress. With lawmakers yet to provide a new statutory structure, regulators are relying on existing authorityโ€”an approach Better Markets says is ill-suited to retail investor protection.

    Key takeaways

    • Better Markets says the CFTC is not designed for primary investor-protection oversight in retail-facing crypto transactions, unlike the SEC.
    • The group disputes the CFTCโ€™s interpretation of Congressโ€™s intent behind the statutory authority it cites for retail crypto frameworks.
    • Better Markets also criticizes aspects of the proposed framework that it believes could permit conflicts through affiliations among market participants.
    • Industry leader Nate Geraci argues the sectorโ€™s push is for clear rules and that regulators may need to act if Congress cannot.
    • The CFTC and SEC are both moving forward on crypto policy without waiting for new legislation.

    Why Better Markets says retail protections could weaken

    In comments tied to the CFTCโ€™s request for public input, Benjamin Schiffrinโ€”Better Marketsโ€™ director of securities policyโ€”argued that the CFTCโ€™s mandate does not align with the protections retail investors typically need. According to Schiffrin, the agencyโ€™s mission centers on regulating commodity and derivatives markets, which, historically, have involved far fewer retail participants than securities markets.

    Better Marketsโ€™ core argument is that investor protections under SEC-regulated securities trading do not automatically carry over to a CFTC framework for retail crypto activity. Schiffrin contended that because the CFTCโ€™s rules do not include the same safeguards applied to securities investors, the agency is the wrong regulator for transactions that involve retail customers.

    In practical terms, Better Markets is warning that the โ€œrules of the roadโ€ for retail crypto could end up less protective than those governing traditional investor-facing marketsโ€”precisely because the oversight structure and statutory investor-protection focus differ between regulators.

    Dispute over CFTC authority and the intent behind it

    Schiffrin also challenged the legal premise behind the CFTCโ€™s proposed approach. Better Markets argued that the statutory authority the CFTC is relying on was originally enacted to address fraud in leveraged precious-metals trading. In Better Marketsโ€™ view, that history does not demonstrate that Congress intended the CFTC to become a central regulator for retail crypto transactions.

    The nonprofit further criticized elements of the framework it believes could permit affiliations between market participants. Better Markets linked this concern to the broader pattern of industry failures that it says contributed to the collapse of FTX, though it did not suggest additional specifics beyond its general objection to affiliation-related risk in the framework under consideration.

    Debate over the โ€œcrypto capitalโ€ argument

    Better Marketsโ€™ critique also extended to CFTC Chair Mike Seligโ€™s comments about making the United States the โ€œcrypto capitalโ€ of the world. Schiffrin questioned the framing, arguing there is no clear justification for treating crypto expansion as an unqualified national advantage.

    In Schiffrinโ€™s remarks, the underlying issue was the perceived gap between policy ambitions and real-world outcomes. He characterized crypto as lacking a meaningful use case beyond speculation and described it as being used for criminal purposes as well as legitimate activity.

    That assessment was directly contested by Nate Geraci, president of NovaDius Wealth Management, who pushed back on the idea that the crypto industryโ€™s goal should be dismissed. Geraci argued that the industry is essentially seeking clear rules rather than asking regulators to promote speculative outcomes. If Congress cannot deliver that clarity, Geraci said the CFTC and SEC may need to step in to establish workable regulatory boundaries, aligning with the direction in which both agencies are now moving.

    CFTC and SEC proceed after the CLARITY Act setback

    The Better Markets comments come as U.S. crypto policy continues moving forward through existing regulatory authorities. According to earlier coverage from Cointelegraph, the CLARITY Act failed to advance in Congress, prompting the CFTC and SEC to pursue their respective efforts without new legislation. The CFTCโ€™s Monday move sought public comment on a potential framework for margined, leveraged, or financed retail crypto transactions under the agencyโ€™s authority, as reported by Cointelegraph in connection with the CFTCโ€™s outreach.

    Within the same broader regulatory effort, the CFTCโ€™s proposed framework also considers a new federal category for crypto trading platforms designed to bring qualifying exchanges directly under CFTC oversight. For investors and market participants, such an approach matters because it could determine which regulator has jurisdiction and what compliance expectations applyโ€”especially for retail-facing services that involve leverage or financing.

    Meanwhile, the SEC has also continued to advance crypto-related measures. Cointelegraph reported that on Thursday the SEC proposed easing some custody rules for investment advisers offering crypto, while separately taking steps to allow limited tokenized U.S. stock trading and issuing new guidance on how securities laws apply to crypto. Taken together, the SECโ€™s actions indicate a parallel effort to shape compliance requirements for crypto products under the securities-law frameworkโ€”precisely the structure Better Markets says the CFTC should not displace for retail investor protection.

    For market participants, the tension running through this debate is not whether crypto regulation should exist, but which regulator should lead for retail protectionsโ€”and what legal tools each agency can practically deploy. Better Markets argues the CFTCโ€™s framework could under-protect retail customers, while the industry response suggests regulators should fill gaps now rather than wait for legislative certainty.

    As the comment process and subsequent rulemaking move forward, readers should watch how the CFTC addresses investor-protection mechanics inside its framework, whether it acknowledges affiliation-related risks, and how the final proposal interacts with SEC policyโ€”especially for retail users dealing with leveraged or financed crypto activity.

    Risk & affiliate notice: Crypto assets are volatile and capital is at risk. This article may contain affiliate links. Read full disclosure

    Crypto Breaking News
    • Website
    • Facebook
    • X (Twitter)
    • Pinterest
    • Instagram
    • Tumblr
    • LinkedIn

    The Crypto Breaking News editorial team curates the latest news, updates, and insights from the global cryptocurrency and blockchain industry.

    Related Posts

    Wrapped Monero Drops 99.8% After Suspected $13.5m Exploit

    Wrapped Monero Drops 99.8% After Suspected $13.5M Exploit

    33 minutes ago
    Dbs Strategy Tests โ€œlose Deposit, Keep Clientโ€ Retention Plan

    DBS Strategy Tests โ€œLose Deposit, Keep Clientโ€ Retention Plan

    2 hours ago
    Wrapped Monero Token Drops 99.8% After Suspected $13.5m Exploit

    Wrapped Monero Token Drops 99.8% After Suspected $13.5M Exploit

    3 hours ago
    Sky Protocol Reports $2b Stablecoin Outflows As It Denies Illicit Claims

    Sky Protocol Reports $2B Stablecoin Outflows as It Denies Illicit Claims

    4 hours ago
    Bitcoin Falls To $60k As Tech Sell-Off Hits Anthropic Token To $87

    Bitcoin Falls to $60K as Tech Sell-Off Hits Anthropic Token to $87

    5 hours ago
    Bitcoin Drops Below $60k For First Time Since July As Market Sells Off

    Bitcoin Drops Below $60K for First Time Since July as Market Sells Off

    6 hours ago

    Search Crypto News

    Featured Crypto News

    Solarious Wins Financefeeds Awards 2026 For Innovation In Renewable Energy Tokenization

    Solarious Wins FinanceFeeds Awards 2026 for Innovation in Renewable Energy Tokenization

    19 November 2026
    How Web3 Companies Can Help Educate The Next Generation: Inside Share To Care World's Mission

    How Web3 Companies Can Help Educate the Next Generation: Inside Share To Care World’s Mission

    14 November 2026

    Latest News

    • Wrapped Monero Drops 99.8% After Suspected $13.5M Exploit
    • DBS Strategy Tests โ€œLose Deposit, Keep Clientโ€ Retention Plan
    • Wrapped Monero Token Drops 99.8% After Suspected $13.5M Exploit
    • Sky Protocol Reports $2B Stablecoin Outflows as It Denies Illicit Claims
    • Bitcoin Falls to $60K as Tech Sell-Off Hits Anthropic Token to $87
    • Bitcoin Drops Below $60K for First Time Since July as Market Sells Off
    • US Senate Advances Prediction-Market Limits Under DEATH BETS Act
    • Lagarde Warns Europe Risks Falling Behind in Tokenized Markets Unity
    • Binance Blockchain Week 2026 in Bangkok to run Nov 28-29, with agenda spanning stablecoins, tokenized assets and AI in finance
    • Lagarde Says Europe Risks Missing Window to Unify Tokenized Markets

    Join 20,000+ Crypto Followers

    • Facebook2.4K
    • Twitter4.5K
    • Instagram7.2K
    • LinkedIn4.3K
    • Telegram55
    • Threads1000
    Crypto.com

    About Crypto Breaking News

    About Crypto Breaking News

    Crypto Breaking News is a fast-growing digital media platform focused on the latest developments in cryptocurrency, blockchain, and Web3 technologies. Our goal is to provide fast, reliable, and insightful content that helps our readers stay ahead in the ever-evolving digital asset space.

    Web3 Digital L.L.C-FZ
    License Number: 2527596
    ๐Ÿ“ž +971 50 449 2025
    โœ‰๏ธ info@cryptobreaking.com
    ๐Ÿ“Meydan Grandstand, 6th floor, Meydan Road, Nad Al Sheba, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

    FacebookX (Twitter)InstagramPinterestYouTubeTumblrBlueskyLinkedInRedditTikTokTelegramThreadsRSS

    Links

    • Crypto News
    • Submit a Press Release
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Disclaimer
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Stocks Breaking News

    advertising

    Tangem 300x300
    © 2026 CryptoBreaking.com | All rights reserved | Powered by Web3 Digital & Osom One

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    Change Location
    Find awesome listings near you!